![]() |
| Emory Cohen and Saoirse Ronan in "Brooklyn" |
Watching "Brooklyn", I was reminded of stories told by an old relative, something familiar and romantic, about the past and how times were different. And yet "Brooklyn", directed by John Crowley, and adapted from Colm Toibin's 2009 novel of the same name by Nick Hornby, is timeless. When we first meet Eilis Lacey (Saoirse Ronan) her demeanor and appearance are one of resignation and compliance, working for a grouchy old woman at a local Grocery in a small village in Ireland. We notice her potential immediately. Her beauty remains untapped, waiting to spill out, and her surroundings, while comfortable, suffocate her. Eilis is an outsider with local ties. Is it possible that there are no suitors, or no jobs for this intelligent and poised young woman? For Eilis, Ireland is only family and familiarity. When the opportunity to make a change, and take the trip that so many have before her, to New York, to the land of possibility arrives, the journey proves irresistible and our story leaps to life. But of course with that change comes the realization of what was left behind, chiefly, her mother and sister, and the promise of what could have been her life in Ireland. Once established in America, she says to her local Priest, "I wish I could stop feeling like I want to be an Irish girl in Ireland." And even though Eilis appears to be taken care of once in New York: she has a room in a boarding house, a job at a department store, begins taking classes at night for accounting, and attends Irish dances weekly, her aching for home is palpable. Home sickness is something real. What could cure it? Love. Enter Tony Fiorello (Emory Cohen), an Italian sap, made for the movies. Eilis and Tony's courtship is out of time, a reminder of restraint and chivalry, it's shocking in its innocence. When Eilis has to return to Ireland and becomes entangled in another potential romance, the conventions of "Brooklyn's" narrative begin to show. But it's the actors, and particularly, Ronan, that make "Brooklyn" something special. Saoirse Ronan is 21 years old, an appropriate age for the character she's playing, and yet she is an actress of remarkable self possession and grace. She provides Eilis with a serene wisdom, and we look to up to her as an audience, we want whats best for her. Ronan's eyes are an alien shade of ice blue, and they pop out at you in every scene. One moment they well up, wet with emotion, the next, they're fiery, brimming with new confidence. It's a quiet performance, but an incredibly moving one. Seeing Eilis fall in love is perhaps the most satisfying thing I've seen in movies this year. And in its depiction of a young Irish immigrant coming to America in the early 1950s, "Brooklyn" reaches through generations, touching on a subject that is prescient today. Its specificity expands and brings to life the immigrant experience while also speaking to any of us who have ever left home, who have ever felt out of place, who have ever wanted to be in love. It has the spontaneity, the tinge of sadness, and the expectation of happily ever after that come with all old stories.

















































